forum.ww1aircraftmodels.com
Product Reviews => New and Old Kits - Add Ons => Topic started by: Brad Cancian on February 27, 2022, 04:57:54 PM
-
Eduard 1/72 Nieuport Ni-17 Dual Combo
Reviewed by Brad Cancian
(https://i.imgur.com/1PkUKDC.jpg)
Item: 7071
scale: 1/72
Price: 24.95 USD direct from Eduard
Review kit kindly provided by Eduard at https://www.eduard.com/Eduard/Plastic-kits/Profipack/Aircraft/1-72/Nieuport-Ni-17-DUAL-COMBO-1-72.html
The Nieuport Ni-17
Most folks are very familiar with the Nieuport series of fighters, made most famous by the Nieuport 11, 17, 21, 23, 24 and 28 models. The Nieuport type 17 followed both the Nieuport 10 and Nieuport 11 into allied service in the First World War. Known for their manoeuvrability, the earlier Nieuport scouts were light and nimble, but under-powered. The Nieuport 17 was powered by the more powerful 110hp LeRhone rotary engine and was one of the first allied scout aircraft to be fitted with reliable gun synchronisation mechanism, allowing the gun to fire through the propeller arc. The aircraft, like its forbearers, gained its extreme manoeuvrability from its light construction and wing lay out – the bottom wing was very narrow in chord, essentially a “semi-wing” (or “sesquiplane”). This aerodynamic layout was a double-edged sword in some respects; if manoeuvred or dived too heavily, the Nieuport could shed its lower wings. The most widely used variant of Nieuport scout, the Nieuport 17 was used by many French and British squadrons and aces on the Western Front in France. The type also served with Belgium, Italy, Russia, the US, and a number of other countries. It was also licence produced in Britain, Italy, and Russia. The aircraft served in front line service in France from July 1916 through to early 1918, and even post war – a testament to the success of the design.
(https://i.imgur.com/M2qTRt4.jpg)
The Bits and Bobs
This kit was released back in 2007, and was a very welcome addition to the Eduard catalogue. It surpassed all previous efforts before it (including the well known Revell and Esci kits), and still is the premiere Nieuport 17 on the market today. The kit comes in Eduard’s older style of box with the orange strip along the top. The box art shows a very dramatic picture of Sergeant Maurice Boyau’s Ni-17 of Escadrille N.77 flaming a German balloon.
Opening the box reveals a large number of goodies. Immediately apparent is that this was not simply a scaling down of their 1/48 kit. Some of Eduard’s earlier “Dual Combo” boxings did not have a complete array of photo-etched parts and decals for two aircraft to be built – rest assured, with this kit there are enough parts (photoetched and otherwise) and decals to build two complete kits to the same standard.
There is a total of 82 plastic parts (41 per aircraft), which are moulded in Eduard’s usual buff coloured plastic, and the mouldings are up to Eduard’s usual excellent standard - clean and crisp with no flash. The wing rib detail is restrained and subtle – perfect for this scale. Initial dry fitting of the parts indicates an almost perfect fit all round.
(https://i.imgur.com/zQfH92F.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/fzpe2ry.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/bjqHEJJ.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/JD0RSWB.jpg)
Now onto the details. Two styles of cowling are included, each with different stiffening ribs. Two styles of upper wing are included in each kit – one with the open centre section and another with a faired over centre section. Interestingly, there are parts to allow the modeller to build the kit with either a 110hp LeRhone or a 80hp LeRhone engine. The engines are nice, but the detail inclined may seek to replace these with more detailed aftermarket items. The kit also includes the cut down cowling seen on the Ni-11 and Ni-21 aircraft – this will allow an easy conversion to either of these versions of the Nieuport with relative ease (thanks Eduard!). The Lewis and Vickers guns are also especially well done. Included also are 4 different styles of windshield, as well as a “cone de penetration” as fitted to some aircraft.
(https://i.imgur.com/WsgjJFb.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/jvlnEcq.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/1QAucjF.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/4jMW49N.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/r6GU23E.jpg)
There are 94 photo-etched parts (47 per aircraft), with the seat belts and instrument gauges being pre-coloured which makes painting easier (although some of the gauges are printed off centre on my example – not a big deal however). The photo-etched parts replace some of the kit parts, namely the kit seat, interior framework and other fine details including an excellent Lewis Gun mount for the top wing. The seat is especially well done with the fine lightening holes being present.
(https://i.imgur.com/vt0FfG3.jpg)
There are two sets of masks included for details such as the wheels and other markings. These are in the usual material favoured by Eduard.
Instructions
The instructions come in a fine 12 page colour booklet with a brief history on the aircraft, a parts break down, paint break down, diagrammatic instructions, and colour scheme profiles. All alternative parts are tagged to the applicable colour scheme in most cases – in some cases, such as in the case of the windscreens, Eduard do not state which style goes with which markings, so some research will be required to get it right. Also included is a rigging diagram. Colour profiles for all of the colour schemes are included in the instructions, although interestingly, Boyau’s marking scheme is not assigned a scheme letter and all that is included is a side profile, making selection of the correct parts and wing markings difficult. Why Eduard has done this I am not sure.
(https://i.imgur.com/WdPuyNV.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/LSsr9So.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/zCGor8X.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/ASVAiio.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/yC5xzNw.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/lftsYLO.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/brPRVq5.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/zXHDTQs.jpg)
Markings for five aircraft are provided:
- Sergeant Maurice Boyau’s Ni-17 of Escadrille N.77, summer 1917;
- Sous Lieutenant Geroges Gynemer of Escadrille N.3, August 1916;
- Sous Lieutenant Charles Nungesser of Escadrille N.65, summer 1916;
- Adjutant Pierre Pendaries of Escadrille N.69, 1916-1917;
- Lieutenant Onokichi Isobe of Escadrille C.1, December 1917
(https://i.imgur.com/FI6qaF7.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/bl4xtDC.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/ggdBmVc.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/pg3Msqq.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/msjZqav.jpg)
All of the markings are French machines, but there are plenty of aftermarket items around for those inclined to model the machines of other nations.
Paint callouts are Gunze paints.
Decals
The decals are in perfect register and no doubt will be easy to handle like Eduard’s other decals. Enough national insignias are present to allow two models to be decaled.
(https://i.imgur.com/Lyx79qR.jpg)
Accuracy
I don’t have a direct set of scale plans to compare to, but the kit looks dimensionally about right compared to some of the online plans I can find. The cockpit details also look pretty spot on in comparison to online references.
Buildability
I built this kit back in 2007 when it first came out. Digging back, I found my old build notes, which I’ll repeat here (and apologies for the old photos – the quality from 2007 wasn’t so great…!).
As per usual, the cockpit was the first to be tackled. The cockpit is very well represented and consists of floor boards, seat, control column, rudder pedals, side wall frames, throttle quadrant, cross bar and some nice pre-printed gauges. Eduard tells you to remove all of the moulded side wall detail from the fuselage halves in preparation for the nice photo-etched side walls. The detail is hard to remove at the forward end of the fuselage due to the shape of the parts. I was also careful to maintain the thickness of the bottom part of the forward fuselage as this edge forms part of the underside of the nose. Care needs to be taken in folding the seat to get the contours to match up with the base. The same applies for the headrest part PE17, as this needs to conform to the shape of the cockpit opening The only down side is that the control column is only represented by a single rod of plastic with no handle detail – in this scale that isn’t too much of a drama however. I had no fit problems whatsoever with the cockpit, and I painted it up in accordance with the kit instructions.
Engine – the kit 110hp LeRhone engine is also nicely represented. The cooling fin detail on the cylinders is a little simplified but still looks good in this scale. Crank case bolts are also very finely done and look great under a wash. The air breather pipes (part A12) are well protected on the sprue but are a little tricky to remove and clean up – care and patience is the order of the day here. Be careful when aligning the engine on the fuselage as clearance with the cowling is tight. Eduard tells you to sand off the propeller hub detail and replace the hub with a photo-etched part – I liked the detail on the plastic part so I left it as it was and painted on the hub after I had painted the prop.
(https://i.imgur.com/swPm4YQ.jpg)
The fuselage halves fit like a dream and no filler was required. The lower wing and underside of the nose is one part which dove-tails into the fuselage halves. Again the fit was excellent and needed no filler but careful clean up around the contoured underside of the nose is needed. The wings have very fine trailing edges although a couple of swipes will be needed with sand paper to just take the seam off the edges. The tail plane and rudder are also finely done and again fit with no problems. The undercarriage struts were easily removed from the sprues and again posed no problems fit or alignment wise (ah it’s great when it all comes together). The only thing I had to watch out for was the fine carburettor pipes on the sides of the fuselage and another underneath, as well as the moulded on control horns on the control surfaces – these are all very finely done and are very easy to break off during construction. The wing struts are very finely done (especially the interplane struts which have some very nice moulded on strap detail) but some have very minor sink holes at their bases – this is easily remedied with a little glue as filler. Be careful fitting the aft V-shaped cabane strut – again this is very finely moulded and is easy to bend out of shape.
At this point I had to choose which aircraft I was going to model as this would dictate the style of upper wing, engine cowling, windscreen and armament. As I quite liked the look of the camouflaged machine (as opposed to the standard silver dope that most Ni-17s came in), I chose the machine of Adjutant Pendaries of Esc N69 (option C in the kit markings). The kit instructions tell you to use the cowling with the double stiffening ribs at the upper side, as well as the wing with the centre section cut out. Unfortunately, Eduard do not tell you which of the 4 windscreen options to use. Fortunately, I had a copy of Osprey’s “Nieuport Aces of WW1” handy – page 60 has a photo of this aircraft which shows the flat windscreen being fitted to this aircraft (represented by part PE15). The photo also shows that this aircraft had a rear view mirror mounted on the centre section – Eduard supply a mirror in part PE22 but again do not tell you which aircraft it apples to. The only armament on this aircraft was the single Lewis gun on the upper wing.
Painting before the upper wing is attached is a must. I used Gunze 85 Sail Colour, Gunze 84 Mahogany and Gunze 312 green, based on paint availability at my local hobby shop more so than anything else. I did deviate slightly from the kit paint scheme – there is a profile of Pendaries’ Ni-17 in “Nieuport Aces of WW1” on page 38, which shows this aircraft with brown painted undercarriage and cabane struts – this is backed up by the photo on page 60 of the same publication. Eduard instructions show these items as painted silver. After a gloss coat, the decals went on with no problems, however my personal thought is that the red on the roundels is a little too bright. A further gloss coat was followed by a wash using oils which “popped” all of the fine details out, notably the fastener detail around the engine hatches and the stitching detail on the forward fuselage decking.
I rigged the aircraft with fine elastic in accordance with the kit rigging diagrams prior to adding the top wing. The top wing also went on without a hitch (thankfully due to the simple strut configuration of the Nieuport this is hard to get wrong). Once the wings were on, I added the undercarriage and the very fine Lewis gun and mounting (which is a mini-kit in itself!). Be careful with the mounting (part PE 24) as it is very fine and requires some tricky folding. Same applies with the Lewis gun – a number of parts have to be cut off from it and this can be easy to mess up. Once this was done, the other minor details were added, followed by a matt coat and some light weathering with pastel chalks and paint chips from silver paint. Done!
(https://i.imgur.com/Gq4viDm.jpg) (https://i.imgur.com/oDAwDWL.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/ZJS69RM.jpg) (https://i.imgur.com/ouSzITC.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/zAfUYjD.jpg)
And what did I do with the other kit, you might ask… well, here she is (or was, at least, as this one is now long gone to the modelling Gods in the sky…):
(https://i.imgur.com/9vWgxGV.jpg) (https://i.imgur.com/lSO0PkH.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/uhj6eYl.jpg) (https://i.imgur.com/S3CFcJa.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/EQr7O8p.jpg)
Just a little bit of fun, wot :)
Conclusions
This kit is quite a breeze to build and will appeal to all WW1 modellers who build in this tiny scale. Detail is very fine, fit is perfect, decals are great, and there are many, many options provided to allow the modeller to build a plethora of aircraft. This kit is a great option for those starting out in WW1 modelling in ‘God’s own’ scale, due to its simplicity of construction and relatively simple rigging. What can I say other than go get hold of one!
Our very sincere thanks to Eduard for the review sample!
-
Thanks for a very informative review Brad, and including your previous build was a great idea - very helpful to future builders of this kit. Speaking of which...
The engines are nice, but the detail inclined may seek to replace these with more detailed aftermarket items. The kit also includes the cut down cowling seen on the Ni-11 and Ni-21 aircraft – this will allow an easy conversion to either of these versions of the Nieuport with relative ease (thanks Eduard!).
Can one build an 11 from this kit? That type been on my to do list for a few years as a friend owns a flying replica.
-
Hi Zac - alas no, you cannot build an 11 from this kit. The Ni-11 had a different wing planform, and a flat-sided fuselage.
From what I can see, you should be able to build a Ni-17, Ni-21 or Ni-23 from this kit.
Cheers!
BC
-
Thanks Brad, I appreciate the info! As you can now tell, my Noop knowledge is pretty minimal - I can see the differences, but not how they're different!