forum.ww1aircraftmodels.com
WW1 Aircraft Modeling => Completed models => Topic started by: RAGIII on August 05, 2016, 07:54:45 AM
-
Well I have finally finished this one more or less. As I plan to eventually put this one in a Diorama I kept the weathering to a minimum pending my decision on the overll scene. I was asked to share my thoughts on building this kit so I will oblige.
As all WNW kits this one is extremely well engineered. Tolerances are tight but not as much as say the Albatros or Pfalz. The detail is awesome as in all WNW kits. I found myself constantly moving back and forth on the directions as it is easy to miss something and or find more/better details a couple of pagers further than I was in construction. I used WNW mixtures for all of the colors and found them to be very satisfactory. I used the "Later" rigging pattern as I felt that was correct, and it eliminated the need to represent the wood filled and wrapped double lines. WNW does show this rigging variant but one must look hard . I found no major issues with the build that were not SELF created! About those I guess it was because this aircraft is larger than I am used to handling that I found myself constantly running the wing tips into things. In particular my Roden SPAD VII suffered a horrible fate! Another thing was that where I found myself picking the kit up seemed to put my wrist in the perfect position to knock off the tail braces and rigging! I lost one of the braces at some point before I totally knocked off the tail planes. I replaced it with an airfoil shaped strut of the appropriate size and went on. Later I lost the other! So I made another copy. While weathering I knocked off one of the copies and couldn't find it on the carpet. Lifted up a box and found one of the originals.
So overall my experience and take on this kit is that it is one of WNW best! If you like the Salmson or are inclined to build a USAS bird GET ONE!
RAGIII
(http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z349/rickgeisler/WNW%20Salmson%20and%20Aviattic%20Figures/DSCF4658_zpsfnqk6w4v.jpg)
(http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z349/rickgeisler/WNW%20Salmson%20and%20Aviattic%20Figures/DSCF4657_zpsqx9b7mgw.jpg)
(http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z349/rickgeisler/WNW%20Salmson%20and%20Aviattic%20Figures/DSCF4654_zpsgokb8rcr.jpg)
(http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z349/rickgeisler/WNW%20Salmson%20and%20Aviattic%20Figures/DSCF4656_zpshp5kpmnv.jpg)
(http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z349/rickgeisler/WNW%20Salmson%20and%20Aviattic%20Figures/DSCF4650_zpskjcub3ds.jpg)
(http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z349/rickgeisler/WNW%20Salmson%20and%20Aviattic%20Figures/DSCF4653_zpsb3kyvvse.jpg)
(http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z349/rickgeisler/WNW%20Salmson%20and%20Aviattic%20Figures/DSCF4641_zps7vxugbgp.jpg)
(http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z349/rickgeisler/WNW%20Salmson%20and%20Aviattic%20Figures/DSCF4633_zpsvktpeccp.jpg)
(http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z349/rickgeisler/WNW%20Salmson%20and%20Aviattic%20Figures/DSCF4635_zps7xalvmti.jpg)
(http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z349/rickgeisler/DSCF4610_zpslo0pzaw2.jpg)
-
Congratulations Rick and thank you for your build log and now these wonderful photos of your superb model. You have done a remarkable job with the painting on this model, the colours are absolutely brilliant and the rigging is sublime, very well done Rick.
Des.
-
Great summary Rick, and absolutely beautiful Build! Your paint work is truly outstanding and the rigging exceptional. I spent a little time checking out the various joins (The gear struts stand out) and your work is "clean" beyond perfection......... This is a real winner!
Cheers (and congratulations on an outstanding Build)
Lance
-
Rick,
Congratulations my old friend. She's an absolute thing of beauty. Fitting tribute to your Master Class skills and craftsmanship. Well Done!
Highest Regards,
Gregory Jouette
-
She's truly magnificent, Amigo! I think she's your best yet. Remarkable craftsmanship all around.
Cheers,
Bud
-
Rick, you have build an outstanding model. Pantjob and rigging looks perfect. Please show us some pics when you put it in a doirama, but I think you can place it on a nice polished wooden base to avoid distraction of this beauty.
Manni
-
This is a beautiful kit in every detail and it was a pleasure to follow its building. Absolutely a masterpiece.
Well done.
Giuseppe
-
Hello Rick,
I completely agree with Bud. This is your best yet! This is a build were all elements are truly magnificent. The build itself, wonderful camo painting and colours, the decaling and the rigging. One of the best Salmsons I have ever seen! Many congratulations my friend!
Kind regards
Patrick
-
As mentioned on FB already, from my point of view your best build so far. Great job, Rick, and congratulations on finishing this beauty!
Cheers
Ondra
-
Hello Rick,
I completely agree with Bud. This is your best yet! This is a build were all elements are truly magnificent. The build itself, wonderful camo painting and colours, the decaling and the rigging. One of the best Salmsons I have ever seen! Many congratulations my friend!
Kind regards
Patrick
Rick, I completely agree with our friend Patrick! Your Salmson is a jewel, my friend!
Cheers,
Ernie :)
-
Really beautiful build, Rick!
Drew
-
Thanks very much for all of the comments guys! I really enjoyed building this one. Now a few days and a clean up of the desk before moving on with the figures and the next builds!
RAGIII
-
Lovely one, Rick. Congratulations.
And I confirm, this is a lovely kit (but then, which WNW one is not?), recommended to anybody deliberating which WNW model to build !
-
Lovely one, Rick. Congratulations.
And I confirm, this is a lovely kit (but then, which WNW one is not?), recommended to anybody deliberating which WNW model to build !
Thanks Przemol! I had your build bookmarked and referred to it often when building mine!
RAGIII
-
Haven't commented very much during your build , but that doesn't mean I wasn't following along . I really enjoyed your build Rick . Your skills have sharpened up wonderfully over the years and this build proves that ! Well done my friend :)
Terri
-
Yes, as stated above - great finish on a beautiful build Rick. Awesome job, and congrats!
Cheers,
Gary
-
It's a great build in every detail. Perfectly done. Regards, Paul.
-
Haven't commented very much during your build , but that doesn't mean I wasn't following along . I really enjoyed your build Rick . Your skills have sharpened up wonderfully over the years and this build proves that ! Well done my friend :)
Terri
Thanks Terri. Your comments are always appreciated!
RAGIII
-
Yes, as stated above - great finish on a beautiful build Rick. Awesome job, and congrats!
Cheers,
Gary
Thanks Gary. I appreciate you dropping by and commenting!
RAGIII
It's a great build in every detail. Perfectly done. Regards, Paul.
Thanks for the generous comment Paul. Greatly appreciated.
RAGIII
-
Yes, that is very, very nice, Rick! After going through your build and seeing the end result I will indeed have to get one! Truly, lovely work!
All The Best,
Marc
-
Yes, that is very, very nice, Rick! After going through your build and seeing the end result I will indeed have to get one! Truly, lovely work!
All The Best,
Marc
Thanks Monty, greatly appreciated!
RAGIII
-
A very beautiful job on the Salmson, Rick. It's great to see such fine work being done on French planes.
-
A very beautiful job on the Salmson, Rick. It's great to see such fine work being done on French planes.
Thanks for the comment. Greatly appreciated.
RAGIII
-
I too have been following this one and am impressed in every way by the result which is to say the least, spectacular. If it is put into a duo I hope that you will not put in too many distractions - this could easily stand on a mirror base on its own and just be an object for serious viewing and admiration.
Stephen.
-
Gorgeous model.
Adam.
-
Quality build RAG111. Very impressed. I've got this down for a kit bash in 1/72 but all those louvres and rocker covers look extremely daunting.
Regards, Steve
-
I too have been following this one and am impressed in every way by the result which is to say the least, spectacular. If it is put into a duo I hope that you will not put in too many distractions - this could easily stand on a mirror base on its own and just be an object for serious viewing and admiration.
Stephen.
Stephen,
I appreciate your input. Right now my thoughts are leaning to something simple including the Aviattic figures.
RAGIII
Gorgeous model.
Adam.
Thanks Adam. Your comment is appreciated as always!
RAGIII
Quality build RAG111. Very impressed. I've got this down for a kit bash in 1/72 but all those louvres and rocker covers look extremely daunting.
Regards, Steve
Thanks for commenting Steve. I am looking forward to seeing your kitbash!
RAGIII
-
I really love the photo showing the engine close-up. Very impressive paintjob. Well done.
One comment, though (please don't understand that as a major critic, it's meant as a proposal, as one can always improve somewhere): Your photos would be better with a wee bit of additional light. It's rather hard to appreciate the aircraft's beauty when you can#t see those lovely little details.
KR,
Stefan
-
A bird of special magnificence, Rick!
Well done :) ;)
vB
-
So nicely done !!! Which of the next IPMS NATS is the best bet for you to attend ?
Ed
-
I really love the photo showing the engine close-up. Very impressive paintjob. Well done.
One comment, though (please don't understand that as a major critic, it's meant as a proposal, as one can always improve somewhere): Your photos would be better with a wee bit of additional light. It's rather hard to appreciate the aircraft's beauty when you can#t see those lovely little details.
KR,
Stefan
Thanks Stefan. My photography continues to be a challenge to say the least. I tried using an additional light on these and they came out better than before but still not quite there. My camera does have settings for exposure time but I still haven't figured out how to use them :-[ When I try I let in so much light that the picture is pure white with no model in the image .
RAGIII
A lovely build :)
Thanks for commenting Justin!
RAGIII
A bird of special magnificence, Rick!
Well done :) ;)
vB
Thanks VB for the generous comment!
RAGIII
So nicely done !!! Which of the next IPMS NATS is the best bet for you to attend ?
Ed
Thanks Amigo! Not sure yet which of the IPMS Nats I am going to shoot for. Time will tell.
RAGIII
RAGIII