Before we close this topic and move on to other modelling subjects, it’s timely to clearly state our Forum policy and approach to reviews.
Despite what one or two might claim, the Forum is not ‘in the pocket’ of any manufacturers, nor do we have any undisclosed deals to promote their products in return for free stuff.
Our reviews clearly identify which company has supplied the item to us for review, and our reviewers take an impartial approach to every item they evaluate.
Brad, Zac and Rick have all given excellent insights into their review approach.
During my journalism career I was involved in reviewing items for several decades – books, records, movies, DVDs and now model items. In all cases the review is written with prospective buyers in mind and addresses the question- is this item worth the money? Do I recommend it?
Our Forum reviews are based around the in-box look because that’s the common ground for all modellers- we open the box and inspect the contents before building. Some modellers are OOB builders, others insist on all of the aftermarket jewellery going. Some are happy with the kit as produced, others will use it as the basis for some creative conversions.
So the in box review is the starting point and the common ground for us all. Our Forum is blessed by having modellers who build straight from the box and others who show us what extra magic can be brought to these kits with aftermarket or their own creative talents. Between our reviews and member build logs and photo posts we cover the field.
Despite what the critics may feel we do not suppress negative comments about the items we review. The companies supplying review samples do so on the understanding we will be fair and impartial. Our reviews will mention a problem or deficiency in a kit if it is evident, but we refuse to pander to those who obsessively attack every new kit to demonstrate their superiority over the model manufacturer.
We have a forum review team to ensure members clearly see this is an impartial review and are not misled by ‘private’ reviews from people who endorse a product but do not disclose they may have a private promotional arrangement with the manufacturer, like the system operated by Internet Influencers who spruik products in return for freebies.
I am happy to discuss our review policy with members and we encourage members to freely discuss models they have purchased or traded. We do not look to suppress discussion of kits, new or old. But we feel all discussions should be open, honest and impartial.
Dave Wilson
Forum Owner & Administrator